What I’ve loved about Wineskins for over two decades now, is its safe environment to exchange our new ideas, or to even stretch our comfort zone. I would like to utilize this format now to raise an issue none of us really want to face head-on, yet this common struggle is decimating us.
Take a deep breath, and let’s be brave together. If there’s one great weakness we’ve mutually experienced through our blessed Restoration Movement, it is the inevitable fracturing within our fellowships. Our tendency towards fragmentation is the “elephant in the room” and it is our Achilles tendon.
The main factor contributing to our division isn’t necessarily what we typically think it is. Our main problem does not stem from the way we individually view Scripture, or how we might understand doctrinal positions like women’s roles, or even how we chose to worship. I think those are all red herrings.
Our inability to maintain unity is due to our lack of one very particular skill. Conflict resolution.
We are afraid of conflict because we are unequipped to manage it. Our anxiety levels skyrocket at the mere thought of confrontation. We therefore repeat an unhealthy cycle, over an over again, one that almost feels like a self-fulfilling prophesy. Conflict, to be clear, isn’t the problem, but not knowing how to deal with it is killing our brotherhood.
I know about this fallout from a painful and very personal experience. Several years back as I ministered in what could be described as a fairly mainline church, we eventually called up the “Church Doctor” when our corporate pain was unbearable. Yes, we reached out to none other than Charles Siburt. Two years after our work with Dr, Siburt concluded, the pain was still too raw for a slim percentage of our congregation, and nothing would satisfy this small group short of my departure.
This is a story that feels as old as time itself. A church has a conflict, the minister moves on or there’s a new set of elders installed, and we repeat the same scenario three to five years later. As a result, we all limp along, somewhat wounded, somewhat cynical. Could this be why so many of our younger people shy away from our churches?
But that’s not the end of the story. We can write a new chapter when God happens to breathe new life into those who are open to His moving. It seems like the Spirit is closest to us in our most difficult times, or shortly thereafter. And, afterwards, once the healing begins, we learn to apply some of the core Scriptures that instruct us on how to live as a community, on how to get along, on how to be the Body.
If we want to thrive in our congregations and see God’s Kingdom increase, we need a new perspective on conflict. If you attempt to implement change, you can be sure there will be conflict. Conflict is almost necessary for growth, because at its basic level conflict is nothing more the friction that happens as two or more opinions are shared. Conflict is neither evil nor harmful, what makes conflict healthy or unhealthy is how we manage it.
Sadly, in our Movement we haven’t had the greatest history of dealing with our conflicts very well. The good news is, once we acknowledge our very real problem, we can turn a new page and embrace our differences, and we can overcome our conflicts through practicing the one doctrine that unequivocally bonds us together, that being, Love. It’s only by this Love that all people will know that we are His people.
Call me old fashioned, but maybe it’s time we revive an old saying in earnest, “In the essentials unity, in the non-essentials liberty, and in all things love.”